I have a fairly simple Insteon setup using the Hub to manage a few scenes. The scenes are generally activated by schedule (time or sunrise/sunset related) and one by a mini-remote which is not really supported by the Android app.
I have had a couple of instances where the hub has failed and had to be replaced, and it seemed to be a fairly ugly process and somewhat of a weak point in the Insteon realm. I have also added voice activated routines into Google Home (GH) and use them to turn off lights as we go to bed and turn on the route to the wine room. There are a few 'three-way light' setups.
I see that GH can do routines based on a schedule and that the schedule can also be sunrise/sunset driven.
So my thought is to retain the 3-way linkages and build GH routines to replicate my other scenes and acquire a smartbutton that will replace the mini-remote. It would seem to me that the approach would operate the same way, but in the event that the hub fails again, I would still have to factory reset all the devices before linking them to the replacement hub, but the scenes are no longer used, so recreating them would be unnecessary.
I also realise that while there is no functioning hub, none of the GH routines would work anyway. Maybe it would be better to leave the scenes set up (as I think the Insteon devices talk to themselves without the hub) and while the hub is 'down' I would only lose voice-activation functions.
As I also see that Nokia has an alternative hub that may be able to control Insteon devices soon, there may be an alternative to the Insteon hub.
Has anyone been thinking of this approach? Is it logical, or an overthinking result of too much turkey and wine ?
I have had a couple of instances where the hub has failed and had to be replaced, and it seemed to be a fairly ugly process and somewhat of a weak point in the Insteon realm. I have also added voice activated routines into Google Home (GH) and use them to turn off lights as we go to bed and turn on the route to the wine room. There are a few 'three-way light' setups.
I see that GH can do routines based on a schedule and that the schedule can also be sunrise/sunset driven.
So my thought is to retain the 3-way linkages and build GH routines to replicate my other scenes and acquire a smartbutton that will replace the mini-remote. It would seem to me that the approach would operate the same way, but in the event that the hub fails again, I would still have to factory reset all the devices before linking them to the replacement hub, but the scenes are no longer used, so recreating them would be unnecessary.
I also realise that while there is no functioning hub, none of the GH routines would work anyway. Maybe it would be better to leave the scenes set up (as I think the Insteon devices talk to themselves without the hub) and while the hub is 'down' I would only lose voice-activation functions.
As I also see that Nokia has an alternative hub that may be able to control Insteon devices soon, there may be an alternative to the Insteon hub.
Has anyone been thinking of this approach? Is it logical, or an overthinking result of too much turkey and wine ?
Comment